Greatest catch in Steelers history, Santonios' Catch over the Immaculate!!

April 20, 2009

user icon
Michael Aspiotes

Greatest catch in Steelers history, Santonios' Catch over the Immaculate!!

           Which catch do you think is the greatest? All the old boys still go with the Immaculate. No surprise there, but I dont think they give Santonios' a chance. I think Santonios' Catch is not only greatest in Steeler history, but all time NFL history!

          I receive the Sporting News and in it they surveyed 20 former Steelers. They ask all sorts of questions. The first of which was as follows.....  BETTER CATCH: FRANCOS' OR SANTONIOS'.                             
                                   FRANCOS                    15
                                   SANTONIOS                   4
                                   TOO CLOSE TO CALL      1            
          Now 15 out of 20 is 75%. Can it be that 75% of Steeler nation think that the Immaculate was a greater catch than Santonios' Catch? Please, do not get me wrong, the Immaculate Reception was GREAT. Truly "IMMACULATE", the shoestring catch, no time left, boots a dynasty and all that great stuff!  Seen it a million times and it always puts a smile on my face, could see it a million more. Hopefully that 75% changes as the number surveyed goes up. I think Santonios' head and shoulders above the Immaculate Reception. Here's my case.

           Well, for one, Santonios' Catch was pure skill. Both the catch and the throw.(Beautiful placement of ball) Immaculate was all luck. Santonios' Catch brought my beloved team 6, count'em, 6 Super Bowl rings. Immaculate got us to the AFC title game. Which was big at the time, we had done nothing as a franchise up till then. The drive leading up to Santonios' Catch made it a great game, the catch and Big Bens' throw made it one of the greatest games in NFL history, Super Bowls included. That drive in th '72 title game was going nowhere fast. Most of all, Santonios' Catch was on the biggest stage in the whole world. Super Bowl XLIII, millions of people watching, 43 ticks on the clock and a Super Bowl on the line. I heard that some tv fans did not get to see the Immaculate play out do to time.

          Maybe it just depends on how old you are. To those folks back in that '72 title game, the Immaculate Reception will always be the greatest play, let alone the greatest catch to them no matter what happened in the past or in the future of the Pittsburgh Steelers and, nothing will ever change there minds.

          I guess I can relate. What I saw on Feb. 1 2009 at around 10pm, was the greatest catch and the greatest play in Pittsburgh Steelers history. No matter what happened in the past or what will happened in the future, and nothing will ever change my mind!!                

 

                                                                                                                                          

                                                                                                                                                

Keywords: Pittsburgh Steelers Satonio Catch

Posted by Michael Aspiotes | Like this post? Share it:
Share on Facebook Share on MySpace Digg This Story Stumble it! Reddit Save to del.icio.us Add to my Technorati Favorites Save to Google Bookmarks Hype it on BallHype.com!


Comments

  1. I'm sorry but the Immaculate is still a better catch. It's 4th and long, the Steelers are down. The fact that the ball gets tipped, almost knocked to the ground, and then caught by Franco who wasn't even where he was supposed to be, and then he takes it all the way to the house by far is better than Holmes' catch. It was an amazing catch but we've all seen jump balls in the back of the endzone before. It wasn't that unique. Franco's and Tyree's catches thus far are the best catches in NFL History. Period.

    Ryan ParishRyan Parish on Monday, 20 April 2009, 16:11 PDT # |

  2. But the immaculate reception didn't win a superbowl.  I know it was the 1st step in the 70s steelers domination, but I think they still would've won 4 SBs without it.  If holmes doesn't make his catch, we may not have been the 1st team to win 6 super bowls

    Rob PrestonRob Preston on Monday, 11 May 2009, 10:23 PDT # |

  3. Hey thanks Rob. I agree. No immaculate, still 4 bowls. No Santonio, no super bowl. Thank both u guys for reading and commenting on my blog.

    Michael AspiotesMichael Aspiotes on Tuesday, 14 July 2009, 03:12 PDT # |

You must be logged in to post a comment.